There’s a powerful moment portrayed in The Chosen where Mary Magdalene seems to lose her grip on the identity Jesus gave her and drifts back toward the darkness He had freed her from. So many people resonate with that scene. I do too. We know what it feels like to fall back into old pits, old patterns, old shame.
But there’s something about that portrayal that stirs a question in me.
If Mary Magdalene had truly returned to her former life after being delivered, wouldn’t Scripture have told us? The Bible does not hide the failures of its heroes. Peter’s denial is recorded in painful detail. Paul’s persecution of Christians is laid bare. Their worst moments are preserved for all of history to read.
But Mary? After Jesus frees her, we never see her falter.
Instead, we see a woman so transformed, so convinced, so set ablaze with love for her Savior that she is the first to the tomb. The first to see the risen Christ. The first entrusted with the greatest news in human history. And when she tells the others, they don’t even believe her.
In a culture where a woman’s testimony carried little weight, Mary stood firm. She knew what she had seen. She knew Who she had encountered. And she did not waver.
Yet strangely, many of us consider Mary an exception to the rule. We don’t like to believe that God uses the ones who were caught in sins we consider beneath us. We want to believe He chooses the people we think should be chosen. But when we look at Peter and Paul, we see a very different picture. Peter walked in Jesus’ inner circle and still denied Him out of fear. Paul was educated, respected, and convinced he understood God so well that he persecuted His people. Their stories force us to confront what I mean.
We don’t want to believe that life’s betrayals and disappointments could ever tempt us to return to places that feel familiar. I want to believe that Mary had an advantage we don’t—that she knew Jesus in the flesh and in the Spirit, and that’s why she never strayed. But if I’m honest, that line of thinking can quickly become an attempt to justify and rationalize my own struggles.
Peter wasn't just one of the twelve disciples. He was one of the three who were most privy to Jesus' heart. He saw the miracles up close. He heard every teaching. And still, in a moment of fear, he denied the One he loved. Three times. Not because he hated Jesus, but because he feared man more than God.
Paul is similar. Brilliant. Educated. Certain he understood God perfectly. So certain, in fact, that he believed persecuting Christians honored Him. It took being struck blind on the road to Damascus for Paul to finally see clearly.
And yet, when we think of Mary Magdalene, we often reduce her to her past. We remember her sins before Jesus more than her faithfulness after Him.
But what if she wasn’t the exception?
What if Paul was?
It is often easier for God to reveal His love to someone who knows they are broken than to someone who is convinced they already understand Him. Pride is far harder to uproot than shame. Knowledge can be a thicker veil than sin.
Jesus washed Mary clean just as completely as He washed Peter of his denial and Paul of his violence. None of their sins were “too much.” Not sexual sin. Not betrayal. Not persecution. Not pride.
And once Mary was free, she lived like someone who believed she was truly free.
That’s the part we miss.
We assume that because we fall back into old struggles, that must be the normal Christian story. But Scripture shows us something else through Mary Magdalene: a heart so captivated by Jesus that the old life lost its grip.
Peter, in his shame, went back to fishing. Back to what he used to do. And Jesus came for him again on the shore and called him back out.
If you feel like Peter today—ashamed, discouraged, tempted to return to what’s familiar—Jesus will meet you there.
But if you feel like you should give up because you keep failing, remember Mary.
Remember that complete transformation is possible. Remember that freedom can be lasting. Remember that your past does not get to define your future with God.
The enemy wants you to believe that relapse is inevitable, that you’ll always go back, that your faith will always flicker.
Mary’s story whispers something different:
When love for Jesus becomes the defining fire in your heart, the old darkness loses its appeal. The spirit of familiarity has to bow before Jesus.
So don’t give up.
Don’t stop pursuing Him because you think you “should be better by now.” Don’t assume your struggle disqualifies you. Whether you are more like Peter, more like Paul, or longing to be like Mary, Jesus meets you in every place.
And He is still in the business of calling people out of graves, out of shame, out of pride, and into life.
Keep going.
Fan the flame.
The freedom He gives is real—and I’m still learning to walk in it too. It’s a lifelong journey. May we find people who are willing to walk it out alongside us, and may our lives quietly encourage even those who struggle to understand what God is doing, drawing all of us a little deeper into who He is.